The injunction granted against Napster by judge Marilyn Platel late last year was stayed until the hearing of an appeal. Napster was unsuccessful in the appeal. While upholding the substance of her decision in favour of the RIAA, the Appeals Court has directed judge Platel to rewrite the injunction. Will she shut down Napster or allow it to operate on a new feepaying basis? Meanwhile, she has appointed a former federal judge, Eugene Lynch, to mediate between the parties