Challenges in evaluating surgical innovation

Date of this Version


Document Type

Journal Article

Publication Details

Published version

Ergina P.L., Cook JA, Blazeby J.M., Boutron I., Clavien P.A., Reeves B.C., Seiler C.M. & the Balliol Collaboration. (2009). Challenges in evaluating surgical innovation. Lancet, 374(9695), 1097-1104

Access the journal

© Copyright Elsevier, 2009




Research on surgical interventions is associated with several methodological and practical challenges of which few, if any, apply only to surgery. However, surgical evaluation is especially demanding because many of these challenges coincide. In this report, the second of three on surgical innovation and evaluation, we discuss obstacles related to the study design of randomised controlled trials and non-randomised studies assessing surgical interventions. We also describe the issues related to the nature of surgical procedures-for example, their complexity, surgeon-related factors, and the range of outcomes. Although difficult, surgical evaluation is achievable and necessary. Solutions tailored to surgical research and a framework for generating evidence on which to base surgical practice are essential.



This document has been peer reviewed.