Date of this Version

September 2004

Document Type

Journal Article

Publication Details

Svantesson, Dan Jerker B. Geo-location technologies and other means of placing borders on the ‘borderless’ Internet, John Marshall Journal of Computer & Information Law, Vol XXIII, No 1, Fall 2004; pp. 101 – 139.
Reproduced with the permission of Journal of Computer & Information Law.

Abstract

Until recently, it was frequently said to be impossible or at least pointless to attach significance to ’location’ in the online arena. Indeed, the impossibility of linking those active on the Internet, to a geographical location was seen as a distinctive feature of the Internet. However, this is all changing. A recent survey revealed that a large number of companies, particularly in the U.S., seek to identify the geographical location of those who visit the companies’ Web sites. While it is still true that Internet communication largely lacks reliable geographical identifiers, several non-technical methods are applied to cater for the need to know the location of those active on the Internet. Furthermore, so-called geolocation technologies are becoming increasingly accurate, and while unlikely to ever be one hundred percent accurate, may, in the near future or perhaps already today, be accurate enough for legal purposes. Yet the questions that these developments give rise to have gained surprisingly little attention in literature. Against this background, the article examines the different ways in which a Web site operator can identify the geographical location of those accessing its Web site, and the legal implications of such identification.

While a range of purposes, such as fraud detection, authentication, content targeting, security and network efficiency has been envisaged for geo-identification in general, and geo-location technologies in particular, it is primarily the use of geo-location teclmologies for conditioning access and legal compliance that is of concern for this article.

Finally by way of introduction, for the purpose of an overview such as the one provided in this article, it is useful to draw a number of distinctions. First, it should be acknowledged that geo-Iocation technologies are not the only ways in which a Web site operator may seek to identify the geographical location of the access-seeker. I therefore distinguish between hard protection provided by geo-location technologies and the soft protection provided by alternative non-technical means. Secondly, since the level of complexity of different geo-location technologies varies greatly, I draw a distinction between sophisticated geo-location technologies and unsophisticated geo-location technologies. Before these different categories are discussed in detail, a few more words should, however, be said about the context in which geo-identification is relevant.

Share

COinS
 
 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.